That was the subject when Mike Ciholas, Founder and President of Ciholas, Inc., joined Claus Hetting, CEO and Chairman of Wi-Fi NOW, on TECH WATCH. You can watch the full interview below or read the Wi-Fi NOW article. This post covers the main technical points.
A CUWB real-time location system (RTLS) handles indoor location tracking with three parts:
• Tags: small battery-powered devices carried by a person, a machine or material.
• Anchors: fixed devices, usually mounted on the ceiling, that receive the tag beacons.
• The host back end: manages the network and runs the location engine that computes each tag's position.
For every location, the system outputs the tag ID, the time, the XYZ position and a quality value for that position. The customer's application turns that data into analytics, safety, tracking, inventory control or security.
The largest example Mike described is a fulfillment warehouse of 130,000 square meters (1.3 million square feet). The system tracks:
• 300 forklifts at 10 Hz
• 2,000 personnel at 2 Hz
That is 7,000 locates per second from one system. Capacity at that level is what separates a pilot from a site-wide deployment.
The CUWB location engine is custom developed. Rather than solving a fixed mathematical formula, it uses a best-fit approach: it finds the point that best fits the data the anchors have produced.
Each anchor is weighted by the measured quality of the signal it receives. Ciholas uses empirically defined methods to judge whether a signal at an anchor has been occluded or interfered with. Anchors with poor signals stay in the solution but count for less.
In the warehouse example, a forklift in an open travel way can be located using many anchors at once, sometimes as many as 100 in a single location. When the same forklift drives into a racking aisle, most anchors are de-weighted. The anchors at each end of the aisle still have a clear signal, so the engine keeps producing a good position.
Because the location engine can use any number of anchors, accuracy depends on how many anchors are in range and how much averaging is applied. Mike shared laboratory results, with no racking or occlusions:
• 6 anchors: standard deviation of about 2.4 cm in XY.
• 24 anchors: under 1 cm standard deviation.
• 24 anchors, 100 Hz tag averaged to 1 Hz: 3 mm standard deviation.
The averaging works because of the system's capacity. A tag can beacon 100 times per second, and the system combines those 100 samples into one output per second.
In practice this is a design choice. A cost-sensitive site can cover an area with fewer anchors. A site that needs the highest precision can add anchors and averaging. In a basketball arena with 55 anchors, a tag could be moved 2 mm and the system detected the move.
Across the entire fulfillment warehouse, 650 anchors maintain a single time domain synchronized to within a few picoseconds.
Systems that split a site into clusters or zones can show anomalies when a tag crosses from one cluster to the next. A single time domain avoids those boundaries and gives the same timing performance everywhere in the building.
CUWB also uses UWB to send data in both directions. Warehouse operators can use the CUWB API to send data to a tag, for example to enforce a forklift speed limit. A forklift can send data back through its tag, such as inertial measurements, speed, status or whether it is on a wire guide in an aisle.
This means the tags and anchors don't need a second radio such as Wi-Fi or Bluetooth for that data.
Each CUWB anchor has two Ethernet ports. With ChainPoE, one PoE+ switch port feeds the first anchor, and that anchor passes power and data on to the next, for 12 anchors on one chain. Mike estimates this cuts switch port and wiring cost by about 90%.
• The ports have no "in" or "out" side, so an installer can't wire a chain backwards.
• For redundancy, the last anchor in a chain can run back to the switch. With power and data arriving from both ends, a single cable fault doesn't take any anchor offline.
• Each anchor uses under 2 watts, meaning 12 anchors can run on a single 30 watt PoE+ port. At the warehouse, 650 anchors draw about 1.3 kW in total.
CUWB tags are sealed for wet and outdoor use, including the occasional accidental wash cycle. For wet or outdoor areas, CUWB anchors can be fitted with a mounting box and sealing kit, and Ciholas provides a range of mounting brackets to make installation easier.
CUWB has no recurring license or software fees. You buy the equipment, install it and own it. Mike pointed out that many buyers are moving away from location-as-a-service and software subscriptions.
Together with low-cost equipment, ChainPoE wiring and installation tools such as optical reference points for surveying, this keeps the total cost of ownership down.
Mike also explained how CUWB differs from the indoor navigation many people expect from phones.
• Tracked RTLS (CUWB): a tag beacons, the anchors receive it, and a central system computes the position for an application. This suits factories, warehouses and sports, where the people and machines being tracked belong to the organization running the system.
• Untracked indoor navigation: the anchors transmit timing signals, and a phone uses them to compute its own position. The anchors don't know who is receiving, which protects privacy. This suits public spaces such as stores, airports, train stations and hospitals.
Ciholas is a member of the FiRa Consortium, which is working to standardize untracked navigation with their DownLink-TdoA protocols.
Claus asked whether UWB and Wi-Fi infrastructure will merge. Mike's view is that the two have different physical requirements:
• UWB anchors work best around the perimeter of a space, use about 2 watts and only need a 100 Mbit Ethernet connection.
• Wi-Fi access points work best in the center of a space and need 30 or 60-watt PoE and gigabit Ethernet.
He expects the two to share the same buildings, side by side, rather than the same box.
• Capacity, accuracy and infrastructure cost decide whether UWB pays off across a whole site.
• Accuracy is something you design for: more anchors and more averaging give more precision.
• A single time domain avoids the zone boundaries found in clustered systems.
• ChainPoE and no subscription fees lower both installation cost and running cost.
Ciholas has worked with UWB for 15 years and builds the whole stack, from antennas to algorithms. To plan a deployment, contact the CUWB team.
In the fulfillment warehouse Mike described, one CUWB system handles 7,000 locates per second: 300 forklifts at 10 Hz and 2,000 personnel at 2 Hz.
In Ciholas laboratory tests, CUWB reached about 2.4 cm standard deviation in XY with 6 anchors, under 1 cm with 24 anchors, and 3 mm with 24 anchors and a 100 Hz tag averaged to 1 Hz.
No. CUWB has no recurring license or software fees. You buy the equipment and own it.
ChainPoE lets one PoE+ switch port power a chain of 12 CUWB anchors through each anchor's two Ethernet ports. It reduces switch port and wiring cost by about 90%, and a redundant loop back to the switch protects against a single cable fault.